Issue #5: Hard Disagree

Share

Appetizer
The demand for transparency needs to be met with more context, not more information.


Main Course
Managing from the middle often means having to relay decisions. Decisions with little consultation that packaged for delivery through you.

Some are easy: A focus on qualifications for the upcoming campaign. Agree.

Others are trickier: An outlandishly high and unattainable fundraising goal for a team. Hard disagree.

Whether it's a mid-level giving strategy or an alumni relations recognition event, there are occasions when you're going to think, "Yes! Love that idea." and times when you're thinking, "Um.. I'm not sure about that."

Relaying decisions does not mean parroting those decisions. Managing from the middle requires, well, management, up and down.

Upwards: you want to make sure your opinion is heard and factored into the decision criteria. You're representing your values and your teams, it's important that those voices are reflected in the conversation.

And then, regardless of how the final decision lands, you support it.

Which brings us to Downwards: Relaying the decision is not enough. Your perspective matters. From your vantage point in the middle you know the reasons as well as the implications.

Tell your team whether you agreed or disagreed with the decision and ultimately why you're supporting it.

Yes. Supporting it.

Because you want your team to see what healthy conflict looks like. You're modeling the same behavior you want them to demonstrate:

How to disagree, but come together to execute. Speaking up - respectfully and with good intention - and then supporting the result in either direction.

Because in the end, your teams don't want to know the outcome, they want to understand the decision.


Dessert
The next decision you've got to relay, carve out time to unpack it with your team and create alignment, with these four steps:

  • Outline the decision - including the context and outcome
  • State your position on the decision - whether you agree/disagree, what you feel is left out, or where the information was incomplete
  • Confirm your support for the decision
  • Open the floor for input