Issue #3: Data Rich, Decision Poor
Appetizer
Think about the best decision you've made in the past 12 months. What data did you use to make it?
Main
"What does the data say?"
Take note the next time you hear someone ask that in a meeting. They aren't asking for data, they're asking for permission.
We've spent the past two decades in advancement becoming data-literate and it worked too well. Data-driven decision-making has become the gold standard. We have dashboards and integrations, business intelligence and giving models; deeper analysis and endless metrics.
From fundraising performance to campaign investment, everything is based on quantitative logic now.
We've reached data nirvana.
And the result?
We've never known more about donors, and donor counts continue to fall.
Reliance on data has made us terrified of making decisions in its absence. When the outcome is less certain or when there's no precedent, there's no confidence. When there's no comparable data or no peer benchmark, there's no safety.
If a decision has to be justified by evidence before you make it, you can only ever decide things someone else has already done. In other words, less unique-thought, less friction among competing ideas, and ultimately, a more generic product for our donors.
The only thing worse than decision-by-committee is indecision-by-data.
Dessert
Take that decision you've been researching for a while and write down what you would need to know that you don't already. If you can't name it, you know it's time to decide.